A commuter bicycle beside a wooden bench along a quiet, landscaped bayside path, with calm blue water beyond.

How Coronado Cays Gets to the Village Without a Car, and What the City Decides Next

"Neither sufficiently serves residents in the Coronado Cays." That was the Coronado Times summing up Coronado's two transit programs after the November 3 City Council meeting. One is the free summer shuttle. The other is the proposed return of the Island Express electric shuttle. Both have been debated for years, and both run into the same problem at the south end of the island.

If you're choosing between Coronado Cays and the Coronado Village, you're choosing between two transportation setups. The city's own numbers show the gap comes from geography, and the reason is State Route 75.

The Road That Splits the Fleet

Most people remember the 2024 Island Express as small electric carts zipping around Orange Avenue. Those carts are Polaris GEMs, and the Coronado Times reported that they can't legally drive on State Route 75, the Silver Strand road that links the Cays to the rest of Coronado.

So the Cays has always needed its own vehicles. According to the City of Coronado staff report, the pilot launched June 4, 2024, as a free, on-demand, door-to-door service run by Circuit. It used six Neighborhood Electric Vehicles in the Village and two eight-seat electric vans assigned to the Cays. It ran 10 a.m. to 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and 9 a.m. to 10 p.m. on Fridays and Saturdays.

Here's how the two halves compared over the six-month pilot, which ran June to December 2024:

2024 Island Express pilot Village Coronado Cays
Vehicles assigned Six NEVs Two eight-seat electric vans
Passengers carried 52,945 5,651
Average cost per passenger About $7 About $29

In all, the pilot cost the city $561,509 and carried 58,596 passengers. The Coronado Times called the Cays service "by far the most expensive piece."

Why the Cays Number Runs About Four Times Higher

A van has to be staffed and charged whether it carries one rider or eight. The Cays had two of them for the whole pilot, and they carried roughly a tenth as many people as the Village fleet. When the fixed cost of a dedicated fleet is spread over a smaller ridership, the cost per rider climbs. In the Cays it ended up about four times the Village figure.

None of this says Cays households don't want a ride. It says that serving the Cays means paying for a separate system, because the cheap vehicles that work in the Village can't use the only road between the two. Every proposal since has run into the same constraint.

What Connects the Cays to the Village Today

As of publication, the Island Express is a proposal, not a running service. That leaves two options for getting off the Cays without a car.

  • MTS Route 901. The route's official timetable, effective January 25, 2026, lists Coronado Cays among its destinations, along with Coronado City Hall, Hotel del Coronado and downtown San Diego. MTS's fare chart lists a $3 adult one-way bus fare, $2.50 with PRONTO LIFE and $1.50 reduced fare. Check the chart before you ride, since fares can change.
  • Route 904 starts north of the Cays. The Coronado route most visitors know runs from the Ferry Landing down Orange Avenue to Silver Strand Boulevard and Avenida de las Arenas, according to its MTS timetable. It runs hourly from September through June. A Cays resident heading to the Ferry Landing would start on Route 901.

The free summer shuttle is a fixed-route MTS bus the city has funded since 2013, apart from a 2020 cancellation and a reduced 2021 season. Its regular route doesn't reach the Cays. The big exception is the Fourth of July. That service carried 498 Cays riders in 2026, down from 949 in 2025, according to the Coronado Times agenda preview. The whole program carried fewer riders that summer after the city switched to 20-seat buses with no standing room. Total ridership fell from 70,585 in 2025 to 64,027 in 2026.

To make up for the limited Cays service in summer 2026, the city gave Cays households 374 PRONTO passes for free rides on regular MTS buses. MTS reports that 81 were used. A free fare didn't change how most Cays households got around that summer.

What the Council Is Weighing for the Cays

The current proposal comes from Via, through Crosby Street Transit LLC. A city selection committee unanimously scored it highest among the bids. It splits the island in two, just like the pilot did:

Proposed service Format First-year cost Annual cost after
Village Year-round, on-demand, electric vans or GEMs About $980,000 About $860,000
Coronado Cays Two wheelchair-accessible vans, five-stop fixed route, every 30 minutes About $455,000 About $360,000

Those figures come before any fare or advertising revenue. The Cays piece is listed as optional. When the council authorized proposals in October 2025, members signaled support for a fare, with $5 a ride suggested, along with cost-sharing with hotels. City staff have also pointed to SANDAG's proposed Flexible Fleet Pilot Program as a possible grant source.

At the November 3 meeting, Councilmember Carrie Downey suggested bringing the summer shuttle and the electric shuttle back to the council together. She also floated a different model for the south end: a service that gathers Cays riders at a single pickup point, the Coronado Times reported.

Here's the order of events:

  1. October 20, 2026. The council voted unanimously to hold off on the Via contract and gave members 30 days to send questions to City Manager Tina Friend.
  2. November 3, 2026. The council unanimously received the 2026 summer shuttle report as information only. Nothing about next summer was put to a vote.
  3. February or March. Cost scenarios are expected back, with both services up for discussion in the new year.

How This Changes a Cays-Versus-Village Comparison

In the Village, transit is an add-on the city keeps adjusting, and the case for it rests partly on Village parking, which the Coronado Times called "a battle." In the Cays, the car is the plan. Any future shuttle there will be a separate van route on SR-75, priced and decided on its own, and it may or may not include a fare.

That shows up in ordinary household planning. Think about how many cars your household will need, how guests without a car will reach Orange Avenue or the Ferry Landing, and what Fourth of July looks like when the island fills up. Those questions get different answers depending on which side of SR-75 you live on. Whether the Cays gets its own van, a single pickup point or nothing new is still open, and the council expects to return to it in the new year.

A Few Direct Questions

Can the Village shuttle carts come down to the Cays? No. The Coronado Times reported that the GEM carts can't legally drive on State Route 75, which is why every Cays plan uses separate vans.

Did the 2024 pilot let Cays riders travel beyond the Cays? The city's launch notice said riders could request trips anywhere within city limits, including the Cays, Loews Coronado Bay Resort and the Village.

Will there be a free summer shuttle next year? That hasn't been decided. The November 3 report was information only, and the council expects to take up the summer shuttle and the electric shuttle together in the new year.

If you're weighing a Cays home against one in the Village and want to know how the commute, the guest logistics and the holiday traffic would work for your household, The Morabito Real Estate Group can walk through it with you, street by street. Request a personalized Coronado market consultation, or browse current Coronado Cays homes for sale with these questions in mind.

Work With Dino

He finds nothing more rewarding than helping someone find the perfect home or ensuring his buyer gets fair market value for their property.

Follow Dino on Instagram